Site 5 Simon Silk – Log 2

By Alexa Gatti and Nicole Maksymiw

On Thursday morning, we met Professor Smith and Professor Brandes at the Arts Trail parking lot. It was 8:30 AM and there was already activity on the trail. A woman with a packet of papers was instructing two other individuals on some topic. Professor Brandes wondered if some citizen science was being conducted. We realized that interviews would be essential to find out more about the ways this site is used by the public: fishing, artistic expression, running, community events, etc.

A this time of day we also noticed the differences in light and shadow formations and reflections on the water.

IMG_5644 Screen Shot 2015-09-28 at 8.36.16 PM

One contact that will be essential to this process is Dick McAteer, Chair of the Easton Redevelopment Authority. He will be able to provide information the development of the Arts trail, past uses of this site (including the silk mill and the railway that once ran through this area). Dick will also be able to tell us more about the future of the site as the mill is redeveloped through Project Silk. Jim Toia and Paul Dearing will be two more important contacts relating more specifically to the Arts Trail and this important aspect of the site’s development. Toia works at the arts campus at Lafayette and was an important player in the created of the Karl Stirner Arts Trail. Dearing, a local landscaper, recently won the contest to design a new piece of art for the trail that will serve to further connect trail users to the creek. It would be interesting to hear why this location is significant to each of them with their own words and perspectives.

This visit, we focused more on the connections and layers at the site. There is a balance between nature and art, which is something made by man, yet it still enhances the area. The end of the Karl Stirner Arts trail has sounds of construction at the silk mill on one side and sounds of the busy highway on the other, which drowns out the sounds of water and animals. The art along the trail presents a contrast between these built elements and the natural state of the creek and trail. Other additions to the site include words or images in chalk on pavement, rocks, and walls. These are examples of organic (or “vernacular”) art by common people who use this space regularly. We noticed a lot of chalk writing (with social and political messages) and objects left behind along the creek (For example, a row of three matching pottery pieces were left in the roots of a tree). In our video we also plan to show how activity changes throughout the day. It became apparent that we should include elements to the project that will reflect the people using the trail, so we hope to bike through the area with a camera to capture the human element here.

IMG_5656

The development of layers over time has sparked our interest as an avenue to explore in our story. There are layers of art, industry, development, nature, history, and time. We hope to reflect the layers we have observed through additional various layers of images, video, and sound in our media production. The historical element incorporates how the land use has changed over time, including the trail as a former railroad track and the establishment of the mill. Some of the trees in the area might even be of similar ages to the mill. Numerous rocky outcroppings along the trail on opposite side from the water might represent these changes over time, as there is evidence of nature reclaiming old spots (such as a former dam area). There is a sense of time somewhere between the generation time that we perceive and geologic time.

Screen Shot 2015-09-28 at 8.49.48 PM Screen Shot 2015-09-28 at 8.50.06 PM

All of the elements and layers are connected in this relatively small area. Water bars drain from the highway down toward the trail and creek, connecting these distinctly different spots. An art piece that includes leaves in the sculpture had a real leaf sitting amongst the constructed ones. A tree has grown around and through rock. People use the trail regularly. New construction is bringing life back to the old mill, connecting the times. The creek purposefully runs parallel to the trail. The layers create such a rich environment.

Screen Shot 2015-09-28 at 8.50.12 PM Screen Shot 2015-09-28 at 8.50.20 PM Screen Shot 2015-09-28 at 8.50.35 PM IMG_5654

Technology and Nature

Screen Shot 2015-09-28 at 1.04.27 PM

The above photo was on top of our guide for the camping trip this weekend. The second cartoon reminded me a lot of my experience climbing half dome. I spent four hours during the middle of the night climbing half dome by headlamp. When I finally reached the top the sun was beginning to rise, and the first thing I did was take out my phone. Because half dome is so high in elevation, it surprisingly gets perfect cell signal. I had known this before my hike, so had messaged the rest of my family who were in Cambodia telling them I would have service and the approximate time I would be up at the top. I immediately facetimed my family from around the world and talked to them and showed them the view and the sunrise. In some ways I think this ability is absolutely amazing. My family can be on a trip thousands of miles away and still experience what I experience and see what I see. I think it is an incredible use of technology. Yet on the other hand I felt slightly impure or off that my first move upon achieving an incredible accomplishment was to pull out my phone and document it. In such a pristine “wild” place it felt weird using technology.

Can’t Keep Nature Down

This weekend, I participated in a 5k walk to fight blindness. It was located at the Bethlehem Steel Stacks which is where Bethlehem Steel used to be located before it went out of business. It has been since renovated into a very nice facility, but the old structures are still all around and very cool to see (fun fact part of the first transformers film was filmed there).

Most of the old buildings are all falling apart and very rusted, but there are some that still stand proudly, striking impressive figures against the sky. Something else that accents this interesting look is the green that is slowly working its way back against the sea of red rust. While walking, I witnessed many plants, even trees sometimes, jutting out from the buildings many feet up in the air.

It was amazing to see these trees seemingly growing from nothing and flourishing. It speaks for how hardy nature is and how everything gets reclaimed by it sooner or later. A steel mill definitely was not the most environmentally friendly structure, and yet now, not that many years after it went out of business, the environment is slowly but surely reclaiming its land. And not only is it reclaiming it, it is adapting to it. The plants have access to higher up structures which give them better access to sunlight. There is more area (in the form of verticality) for plants to grow. It is fascinating to see this transition back to nature from a once industrialized area.

The split between nature and industry also strikes a cool dichotomy. As mentioned before, the color scheme between red and green is appealing in itself. But it also always surprising to see a patch of green perched haphazardly off the edge of a two story crumbling building or wrapping its way up a rusty old stairway. In time, the green will eventually take over and the red will succumb, but until then, the picture they paint is unforgettable.

Discussion Passages for Class

“We need to honor the Other within and the Other next door as much as we do the exotic Other that lives far away- a lesson that applies as much to people as it does  to (other) natural things” (Cronon 89).

“The removal of Indians to create an “uninhabited wilderness”- uninhabited as never before in the human history of the place- remind us just how invented, just how constructed, the American wilderness really is” (Cronon 79).

“The virtues of a superior man are like the wind; the virtues of a common man are like the grass; the grass, when the wind passes over it, bends” (Thoreau 188).

Discussion Quotes

“This, then, is the central paradox: wilderness embodies a dualistic vision in which the human is entirely outside the natural. If we allow ourselves to believe that nature, to be true, must also be wild, then our very presence in nature represents its fall. The place where we are is the place where nature is not” (Cronon 80-81).

I find the ‘debate’ on if humans are a part of nature or not very interesting. It is something I think a lot about, and I still don’t personally have a solid opinion on the matter yet. I thought it was interesting that Cronan is so sure we aren’t a part of nature, especially because a lot of people would say we are a part of it.

“Not till we are lost, in other words, not till we have lost the world, do we begin to find ourselves, and realize where we are and the infinite extent of our relationships” (Thoreau 187).

This sentence comes after he is describing walking through the woods in the dark, and while he is able to feel his path, others often can’t, and they get lost. I thought this was going to end with something along the lines of this is how we begin to understand nature and our surroundings, but he jumped to relationships which of course could be human ones, or with nature. I thought this was interesting. He is suggesting that to be lost is to be able to take an outside view of the relationships you have with nature or others, because when you are a part of it, it becomes hard to understand or see how much it effects you.

Passages of Interest

“Those who have celebrated the frontier have almost always looked backward as they did so, mourning an older, simpler, truer world that is about to disappear forever. That world and all of its attractions, Turner said, depended on free land– on wilderness. Thus, in the myth of the vanishing frontier lay the seeds of wilderness preservation in the United States, for if wild land had been so crucial in the making of the nation, then surely one must save its last remnants as monuments to the American past–and as an insurance policy to protect its future” (Cronon 76).

“But, wherever a man goes, men will pursue and paw him with their dirty institutions, and, if they can, constrain him to belong to their desperate odd-fellow society. It is true, I might have resisted forcibly with more or less effect, might have run “amok” against society; but i preferred that society should run “amok” against me, it being the desperate party” (Thoreau 187).

a drive north

This weekend I spent time driving up to Syracuse NY to visit my brother for his first Family Weekend! From Lafayette, it is about a 3 hour drive, mostly along I-80 and I-81. There were two times on the way up that I wanted to stop, get out, and take pictures, and relax while watching nature. The first was traveling through Wind Gap. I left at 7 in the morning, so there was still fog in places, especially through Wind Gap. The clouds were still hanging in the valleys! It looked so pretty – and reminded me of Iceland because there, the clouds are always getting stuck on the mountains. As I continued my drive, I drove through rocks and found myself wondering their geologic history and composition because they looked so neat. Along the way I also passed the exit for the lignite museum – which is coal. This was near Scranton and I couldn’t help but think that would have been interesting to stop at, but I was alone, and on a schedule.

The place I really wanted to stop at the most, was between Tobyhanna State Park and Wayne, PA. Here the trees were changing color already, and many were bright red. There was a field among the forest, and it looked almost as if there had been a wildfire in the somewhat recent past. The underbrush was very dense and the trees had very little branches except at the tops. A little further up, there was a beautiful lake, being advertised as part of a sporting area used for ‘sporting weekends’. On the other side there was a small dock, and a car there. I wanted more than anything to hang out at this pond/lake for a bit and see what else was around there. I remember from Bio 102 that Tobyhanna has a different climate to it, and at this time of the year, just driving through, you could tell it was definitely different from the areas north and south of it. It would have been a great place to hike!

It is odd to see such a natural place on either side of a highway where the speed limit is 70. Everyone bolts past the beauty. The area has been altered for the highway, and not many people would even pay attention to the wilderness that is left, and there wasn’t even a place to pull off to soak it all in. Its sad to think the beauty is being ignored.

Discussion of Passages

“God was on the mountaintop, in the chasm, in the waterfall, in the thundercloud, in the rainbow, in the sunset. One has only to think of the sites that Americans chose for their first national parks–Yellowstone, Yosemite, Grand Canyon, Ranier, Zion–to realize virtually all of them fit into one or more of these categories”

I had never examined how national parks were chosen and I found it very true and very interesting that those that were the most aesthetically pleasing were the best protected. Other ecosystems such as wetland may actually have more valuable ecosystem services and biodiversity to protect, but they were not as well protected because they did not have the feeling of God.

 

“Society is commonly too cheap. We meet at very short intervals, not having had time to acquire any new value for each other. We meet at meals three times a day, and give each other a new taste of that musty old cheese that we are”

In some ways this passage speaks to me. Like Thoreau, I hate small talk and find it an annoying part of society. Yet I believe the more time you spend with a person the more interesting and relevant the conversation becomes. It does not have to be new things that have occurred in the recent hours since you last saw each other but instead conversation could be about the past and about learning each other’s true personalities.

Reading Response

“husbandry is degraded with us, and the farmer leads the meanest of lives. He knows Nature but only as a robber”. (180)

This quote from Walden talks about Thoreau’s frustration about the lost art of husbandry and his disappoint in farmers and those who practice husbandry for the purpose of cultivating what they grow for themselves or profit without appreciation for the act of growing it.

“There he passes his days, there he does his work. There, when he meets death, he faces it as he has faced many other evils, with quiet uncomplaining fortitude (77).

This quote is actually by Theodore Roosevelt but is mentioned by Cronin when he begins to define Wilderness in terms of the frontier. I liked this quote because, like Cronin suggests, the frontier is a last, shrinking unclaimed wilderness and freer than any modern civilization. He admires those who went out to frontier to live that admirable life. But I think at the same time those are the same people who began to make it civilized..

Uncommon Ground Reading Response

“The special power of the tree in the wilderness is to remind us of this fact. It can teach us to recognize the wildness we did not see in the tree we planted in our own backyard. By seeing the otherness in that which is most unfamiliar, we can learn to see it too in that which at first seemed merely ordinary. If wilderness can do this–if it can help us perceive and respect a nature we had forgotten to recognize as natural–then it will become part of the solution to our environmental dilemmas rather than part of the problem.” (88)

This passage hits home because it tells us that our home can be the wilderness.  Someone can seek out such places as the Grand Canyon, Muir Woods, or a hike 50 miles away but their own backyard doesn’t deserve the same attention and love as those others? Is that why we can’t protect our entire planet, because we only value the protected or famous wilderness areas?

“The curious result was that frontier nostalgia became an important vehicle for expressing a peculiarly bourgeois form of antimodernism.” (78)

The modernizing world had become too overbearing for the wealthy who had created it, so they sought out the untouched land. Their idea of wilderness mirrored those who came before them and transformed this frontier.