Challenging Thoreau: In Touch with Nature or Out of Touch with Humanity

“Pond Scum: Henry David Thoreau’s moral myopia”

 

As soon as I scrolled past this article title on Facebook the other day, I was obviously intrigued. I have at times taken issue with Thoreau’s harshness in criticizing others for not living as he did, particularly given that his escape into the wild has never been genuine enough for my liking. Though I appreciate him as a writer, it has been difficult for me to wholly appreciate Walden because I find a considerable amount of his commentary to be unnecessarily judgmental and closed-minded, which is disappointing because I feel environmentalists who wish to instill the love of the unknown and unchanged ought not to represent these qualities.

The writer of this article is at times sassy and always critical, but she gives credit where credit is due, for example in her praise of his mastery of nature-writing. Never does she question his brilliance or relevance, but she tears the legitimacy of Walden limb from limb which is interesting to see whilst currently reading the book.

I think the most representative passage from the piece is, “The hypocrisy is that Thoreau lived a complicated life but pretended to live a simple one. Worse, he preached at others to live as he did not, while berating them for their own compromises and complexities,” a feeling I think has been echoed in out-of-class musings of classmates and peers who see me reading the book.

 

Anyway, definitely definitely worth the read for anyone who wants to challenge any ideas they may have about Thoreau or Walden!

http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/10/19/pond-scum?mbid=social_facebook

 

Photograph or Photocopy?

(I wrote this a few weeks ago but appear not to have published it, oops!)

 

I thoroughly appreciated President Byerly’s interpretation of the National Parks system as an aesthetic manipulation of the American landscape (as I read it from my sun-baked seat on the quad yesterday afternoon) because I felt she explored it philosophically and with passion. Though I’m sure you’re all feeling beaten over the head with it by this point, this piece clearly reminded me of my trek around some of America’s National Parks in the West/Southwest. As we toured a number of the parks I was often annoyed by the hoards of humans with their selfie sticks and flashing cameras all crowded around the same “scenic view” or “outlook point”. And yet these are the places we feel compelled to go to because it feels as though someone is telling us, “hey- over here, this is what you’re looking for!”

My particular experience with the parks was very naive and unplanned and wholly beautiful. For the majority of the trip I was only with my boyfriend Sacha, who is at least as naive and unplanned as I, so our curiosities about the parks and what they could offer us were usually fulfilled- no matter how that seemed to turn out (many a sore limb and grumbling tummy did result form our choices). I thought it might be interesting to include here some photos that I feel resulted from some of our treks off the beaten path as well as some that are so cliche they merit a cringe or two. I would like to think of these ideas here as I think Byerly’s philosophy might dictate- as either photographs or photocopies.

~photocopies~

DSCN1536

a tripod shot of the Colorado Flatirons so touristy my CO-native friend Topher (shown right) laughed and ran away moments after the shot.DSCN2069

the “Titanic pose” at perhaps the most crowded “overlook” we visited, at the Grand Canyon of Yellowstone.

~photographs?~

DSCN1649

at Arches National Park, Sacha and I took a detour into what we thought might have been a trail but turned out definitely not to be. I would imagine this isn’t a shot you see on the postcards.

DSCN1966

very touristy but striving for a “different” take on the “Sapphire Pool” at Yellowstone National Park.

IMG_0309

a shot from the previously blogged-about explorative hike up into what we hoped would be bear country. in this moment the view felt untouched, and I think represented an appreciation for the park (Yellowstone) not tarnished by its economically relevant beauty.

Environmental Justice from a Few Angles

When we spoke about Central Park in class today, a thought kept nagging at me pertaining to an article I stumbled upon months ago. According to this article, and to articles I located today on the same issue, a portion of Central Park exists on the land formerly known as Seneca Village. Seneca Village was a largely forgotten community comprised of 2/3 African American and 1/3 Irish inhabitants. It was one of the first communities in the United States that housed a majority of African American homeowners. When the park was built, these people were forced from their homes, and by all accounts never re-established the style of lives they had in the Village once they were displaced.

I think it was critical for Central Park to exist, and I think it is integral in the well-being of New York City residents, but when the documentary today began to explore the trends of elitism that pervaded its early populations, I was again left questioning the racial implications of the project and how grand the impact of its construction may have been in the perpetuation of institutional racism and deprivation of resources to African American families.

This article is quick but it kind of lays out some of the frame for why this matters. I think Environmental Justice is really interesting and I think it is something we could explore more in class because so far I would say the majority of our literature has focused on a very white, often male, perspective of the adaptations of land and culture that surround our thoughts on nature and I would be curious to see if we could integrate some other-cultural perspectives in our dealings with what best upholds the marriage between man and land.

 

http://cute-n-tiny.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/3364851456_4a149b2952-400×265.jpg

 

Truckin’

This fall break I made the journey to and from Exeter, NH as I usually do, but I did it with a much shorter interval of time between drives. I drove home Sunday evening and returned to Lafayette Tuesday evening. Both trips took roughly 6 1/2 hours, but on Sunday I was alone, and on Tuesday I had four passengers. Not only was I thrilled to have company, and subsequent entertainment, I was stoked to provide transportation for those who might otherwise utilize their parents or a similarly under-utilized (in terms of capacity) mode of transportation. I thought to myself “this is why I drive an SUV” (though it is difficult to seriously call my ’06 Mercury Mariner and “SUV”).

So we loaded up the cargo space, tossed a roof storage sack on top, and were on our way. Now, my car is not very impressive with gas mileage. It breaks my heart to see how quickly the little arm drops on the fuel gauge, but I always keep track of what my MPG averages seem to be, just so I kind of know. On the way home, I was averaging over 21 MPG, which is not impressive or great by any stretch, but for a 4WD vehicle in Jersey, NYC, and Mass Pike traffic, it wasn’t bad. However, on the way back to school, I started to notice pretty quickly that the little arm was dropping rapidly in comparison to the recent identical drive. By the time we got back to Lafayette, I estimated the MPG for the trip was barely over 17. This was moderately traumatizing to me. 17?!?

So, this got me thinking. In this context- and perhaps in others- where is the sweet-spot of eco-conscious carpooling before it treks into this mileage-reductive realm I seem to have entered last night? I assume it was because with four extra people and all of their belongings (presumably cold weather apparel of the weighty variety) the little engine that could really couldn’t. I definitely felt more resistance when I tried to accelerate, and the car just generally felt a little laggy. But 21 to 17 is a fairly significant decrease. I wonder if this is true for other cars, and if so, what it means about smart carpooling?

Free Fallin’?

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/16/science/gopro-balloon-footage-of-earth.html?WT.mc_id=2015-KWP-AUD_DEV&WT.mc_ev=click&ad-keywords=AUDDEVREMARK&kwp_0=45522&kwp_4=256068&kwp_1=191479&_r=0

I stumbled across this video and accompanying summary this morning and was pretty amazed. I feel skeptical about it’s legitimacy but that may just be me. Regardless, very cool, I hope that more videos like this surface in the future. I would like to see one of certain parts of the ocean or perhaps of the Himalayas or something like that.

New Legs

This summer I listened to a lot of podcasts, and a lot of my favorite podcasts are the TED radio hour compilations. If you haven’t listened to them, I highly recommend them- each one is a collection of segments from TED talks on the same topic with follow-up conversations with the people who originally gave them. One of the best ones that I listened to this summer had to do with humans and our physical interactions with technology. The most memorable of the talks featured in the podcast was by Hugh Herr, a mountain climber who lost both of his legs from the knees down after he was caught in a storm on Mount Washington in New Hampshire. As he had been an avid and gifted climber prior to his accident, he refused to accept that he would have to surrender a recreational escape that had been so meaningful to him so he worked incessantly to develop prosthetics that would allow him to return to the activity he loved. He jumped off from this point and now works to create comfortable prosthetics for all kinds of people so that amputees no longer feel they are less-than, and are allowed to feel again that they are wholly human, if not more.

Aaron’s comments on hiking and the challenge triggered my memory of this TED talk because I believe Herr says something about how it had always been a challenge to climb and his recovery had been a challenge to return to being able to tackle those cherished challenges again. Definitely worth checking out:

Tossed

I can’t believe I haven’t blogged about this yet, but last Saturday I had the glorious opportunity to return home. Not home as in New Hampshire, but home as in the sea. Each September, the Lafayette swim team (and this year the divers!) pile in cars in the wee hours of the morning and head to Belmar, New Jersey for a charity swim benefitting brain cancer research. It is important to us to support the swim team that puts on the event, but it is also a fun-filled retreat of sorts for our little tribe.

Anyway, so the “race” is a mile long ocean swim and it is absolute madness. In an attempt to coordinate the insanity, the race directors have competitors enter the water in “flights” but this just results in a frenzy of those in later flights literally trampling those who leave first. It is a thrashing, crashing, splashing, clawing brawl of bodies. It takes from 20-30 minutes but it feels like an instant because the entire event is a campaign for survival.

I love it.

It dawned on me this year that amidst this chaos, I felt supremely content. Swimming has always been an important part of my life, and so has the ocean, but only a few years ago did swimming (in an athletic sense more than a splashing-around-in-the-waves sense) become a passion for me. It is so vastly different from pool swimming, or even lake swimming. It is colder, obviously saltier, and so much more threatening. It is beautiful.

Usually when I go for a longer swim in the ocean, it is with the lifeguards I have worked with for many summers. We all enter at the same time and battle our way through the waves before we get just past the break and chart our own courses. It is far more independent than the ocean swim we participated in on Saturday. To enter the mindset in a hypothetically present tense:

I am entirely at the mercy of the single most powerful entity on this earth. I am intimately aware of my fragility and yet astounded by the willingness of the sea to cradle and rock me with each set of waves that rumbles toward shore.

This kind of experience is something I hope never to take for granted. Amidst the hundreds of flailing, violent, churning bodies a few days ago, I almost lost track of this feeling. But after a moment or two, I could surrender to the Atlantic, the beautiful Atlantic, and it didn’t matter how many scrappy boys scratched my legs or grabbed my feet, I was home.

Story of Place : Ginny, Shawn, Maggie – Supplemental Photos

It is possibly hard to imagine why we are all so fascinated with our little Butz Mill river spot without being able to see it for oneself. So here are some photos of our favorite treats so far:

DSC_0902

upon arrival of our hillside entry point, we noted a suspicious and alarming needle. we did not find any other needles after the initial sighting but we did notice a number of spoons, leading us to believe more concretely that this is a location frequented by heroin addicts and other drug users.

DSC_0905

despite the abundant garbage, this place is so lovely.   DSC_0908

a shot of the whole dam from about halfway across the river (thanks waders).

DSC_0911

we were intrigued to note some children’s play things on the far shore once we had crossed the creek.

DSC_0915

The Easton Public Works building hides just beyond the trees at the lip of the creek, here is a pile of cigarette butts, nearby was an abandoned can of worms and some footprints. Perhaps our lovely little creek hideout is a popular lunch or fishing spot for the workers.   DSC_0919

We were very interested in this apparent throne constructed from old stone materials. What was the original use for these stones? And who constructed this current structure? This really began to trigger some of our thoughts about infrastructure and its relation to nature. There is a sort of cyclical use of materials that matches the cyclical nature of an aquatic ecosystem. We will continue to explore these ideas with future findings such as this one.

DSC_0921

View of the wall from the bottom, above is the road.DSC_0922

One of many funky bricks we stumbled upon. This one was Ginny’s favorite.    DSC_0927

Spotting a ladder beneath the surface.

DSC_0936

Some wildflowers reclaiming an old trailer near the Public Works buildings. DSC_0939 DSC_0941 DSC_0942 DSC_0943

DSC_0945

Some gems of Easton’s past. Traffic lights, road signs, etc.    DSC_0949

Trekking back down in our stylish ensembles. DSC_0951

Funky little critters on another neat brick.

DSC_0952

Ginny moving around some (possible?) building materials. More connection to infrastructure and nature.

DSC_0960

My favorite bit of pottery/ceramic from the river. Things like this are scattered everywhere. Some seem old, some seem newer, all seem perplexing in their abundance.DSC_0961

A brick we ultimately took with us for further exploration and hopeful identification. DSC_0962

Ginny leading the charge to see the other side of the dam.DSC_0966

Ta-da! A pristine view from atop the dam.

Late to the Party but Still Paddlin’

I suppose I’m a little slow to the game here but after a much needed 2+ hour phone call with my wonderful mama (broken phone leaves little time or possibility for such extended moments of contact) I have some new thoughts on our meander down the river on Saturday. Much like what a lot of other people, namely Terry, said about the experience being akin to a childhood experience, I found that many of the feelings I recognized physically brought me back to certain moments of my youth. My mom and I spent a good chunk of time today wondering about what children a generation from now will be like and how much different the population’s general activity level is now from how it was in her time or before. We figured in how much time people spend in their cars and offices and homes and how appliances lessen the simple physical tasks of laundry and dishwashing and essentially anything that can be made more efficient with a touch of a button.

She was fortunate enough to grow up in an active family that cherished the outdoors- her father ran a summer camp in his time between teaching high school history, and she and her sisters rode and cared for horses throughout their preteen and teen years. In part because of this, and in part because of my birth occurring riggghhhttt before the technological revolution of the youth, she was able to instill in my sister and me a sense of belonging in nature. She nurtured our interests in snakes and snails and stifled our interests in television. I think it is partly because of this that I so appreciate being able to be alone in the nature that I love.

I think that is part of why I was apprehensive about taking on the Delaware in the company of so many people. To my surprise, I was actually most ruffled up about Ian and Katie being there. It felt like we were all going in on this excursion together and that they weren’t a part of it so somehow their presence would lessen the experience. I was excited to do something I have always loved doing but I was nervous about what it would feel like, with these people, in this setting, in this way. To my pleasant surprise, it was much more freeing than I anticipated. In fact, though I definitely spent the majority of my time pulling forward or to the outsides to be able to kind of do my own thing and see things for myself, some of my favorite parts of the journey were when we were all tethered together and drifting. There was something about that that was at once relaxing and engaging, and it was a new perspective on an encounter with nature for me that I would be interested in repeating.

I know at some point, Joe, Erik and I started to imagine what the camping trip will be like. It was once we had left for the second “half” of the excursion and we were at the front of the group where the water was clear and flat save for the occasional ripples and rocks. The reflection of the trees made it all seem so much fuller, and the frequency of visible housing diminished. With the large hills/small mountains in front of us, it was easy to begin to picture what it might be like out there in the Catskills. I think I will again begin to wonder about the size of the group and the number of the people while we are hiking and such, but I am looking forward to what I now expect to be more pleasant surprises.

Crowfoot, Crowfoot Why the Tears?

When we watched the short litter-prevention ad of the “Crying Indian” I was promptly reminded of an exhibition I once visited that centered on the indigenous people of Canada. Amidst traditional clothing, hunting tools, building tools, and other artifacts and pieces of information, there was a small screening room that featured the short film/long music video I am posting here. It’s dense and historic in content but I have watched and listened to it so many times I’ve lost count. It speaks to the strengths and sorrows of the native people of the North American continent who have historically recognized and respected the natural world far more than their immigrant, namely colonial (and us as descendants) counterparts.

It is a moving piece if you devote the time to it, featuring pleas to remember the importance of the drive to save the buffalo and stand their ground, and lamenting of the loss of life at the hands of those who didn’t care enough to preserve it. I think it would be cheap to offer too much of my own interpretation without opening it first to anyone who wishes to form one of their own, but I find it an important and memorable piece of Native art and music.

<iframe src=”https://www.nfb.ca/film/ballad_of_crowfoot/embed/player” width=”560″ height=”315″ frameborder=”0″></iframe><p style=”width:560px”><a href=”https://www.nfb.ca/film/ballad_of_crowfoot” target=”_blank”><em>The Ballad of Crowfoot</em></a> by <a href=”https://www.nfb.ca/explore-all-directors/willie-dunn/” title=”more films by Willie Dunn” target=”_blank”>Willie Dunn</a>, <a href=”https://www.nfb.ca” target=”_blank”>National Film Board of Canada</a></p>