Challenging Thoreau: In Touch with Nature or Out of Touch with Humanity

“Pond Scum: Henry David Thoreau’s moral myopia”

 

As soon as I scrolled past this article title on Facebook the other day, I was obviously intrigued. I have at times taken issue with Thoreau’s harshness in criticizing others for not living as he did, particularly given that his escape into the wild has never been genuine enough for my liking. Though I appreciate him as a writer, it has been difficult for me to wholly appreciate Walden because I find a considerable amount of his commentary to be unnecessarily judgmental and closed-minded, which is disappointing because I feel environmentalists who wish to instill the love of the unknown and unchanged ought not to represent these qualities.

The writer of this article is at times sassy and always critical, but she gives credit where credit is due, for example in her praise of his mastery of nature-writing. Never does she question his brilliance or relevance, but she tears the legitimacy of Walden limb from limb which is interesting to see whilst currently reading the book.

I think the most representative passage from the piece is, “The hypocrisy is that Thoreau lived a complicated life but pretended to live a simple one. Worse, he preached at others to live as he did not, while berating them for their own compromises and complexities,” a feeling I think has been echoed in out-of-class musings of classmates and peers who see me reading the book.

 

Anyway, definitely definitely worth the read for anyone who wants to challenge any ideas they may have about Thoreau or Walden!

http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/10/19/pond-scum?mbid=social_facebook

 

Corn: We need it and it needs us

Corn is a fascinating organism. We use corn for everything from food to biofuel to feed for farm animals. A DNA test of a single human hair shows that the average American’s carbon content is 69% from corn. That’s a huge percentage! So clearly we have some form of dependency on corn in our lives the way that they are operating today. What I find fascinating though is that corn needs us in order to reproduce. Should humans vanish off the face of the earth today, corn would vanish with us. The nature of the kernel, covered carefully in its husk and in extreme close proximity to many other kernels would not be able to disperse or survive without the help of human propagation. I find this to be quite ironic, our co-dependency upon one another, humans and corn.

Sustainable Cities Index

After our class discussion about green cities today, I was eager to do some further research on the topic. Estimates show that about 70% of the planet is likely to be an urban center by 2050. Cities already account for 55% of the world population, 80% of all energy use, and the most emissions of greenhouse gases. This begs the question of how cities might be able to balance the needs to be both economically dynamic and environmentally responsible. It appears that many cities are better at one aspect than another, such as US cities being economically dynamic and not very environmentally conscious.

I found an index of sustainable cities by Arcadis, a Dutch design group. It is based on data sets under people, planet, and profit categories. This index ranks Frankfurt, London, and Copenhagen as the top three cities, and the US cities do not appear until the fifteenth slot with Boston. I found the infographic below quite interesting after today’s class period.

http://www.sustainablecitiesindex.com/

arcadis-sustainable-cities-infographic

Photograph or Photocopy?

(I wrote this a few weeks ago but appear not to have published it, oops!)

 

I thoroughly appreciated President Byerly’s interpretation of the National Parks system as an aesthetic manipulation of the American landscape (as I read it from my sun-baked seat on the quad yesterday afternoon) because I felt she explored it philosophically and with passion. Though I’m sure you’re all feeling beaten over the head with it by this point, this piece clearly reminded me of my trek around some of America’s National Parks in the West/Southwest. As we toured a number of the parks I was often annoyed by the hoards of humans with their selfie sticks and flashing cameras all crowded around the same “scenic view” or “outlook point”. And yet these are the places we feel compelled to go to because it feels as though someone is telling us, “hey- over here, this is what you’re looking for!”

My particular experience with the parks was very naive and unplanned and wholly beautiful. For the majority of the trip I was only with my boyfriend Sacha, who is at least as naive and unplanned as I, so our curiosities about the parks and what they could offer us were usually fulfilled- no matter how that seemed to turn out (many a sore limb and grumbling tummy did result form our choices). I thought it might be interesting to include here some photos that I feel resulted from some of our treks off the beaten path as well as some that are so cliche they merit a cringe or two. I would like to think of these ideas here as I think Byerly’s philosophy might dictate- as either photographs or photocopies.

~photocopies~

DSCN1536

a tripod shot of the Colorado Flatirons so touristy my CO-native friend Topher (shown right) laughed and ran away moments after the shot.DSCN2069

the “Titanic pose” at perhaps the most crowded “overlook” we visited, at the Grand Canyon of Yellowstone.

~photographs?~

DSCN1649

at Arches National Park, Sacha and I took a detour into what we thought might have been a trail but turned out definitely not to be. I would imagine this isn’t a shot you see on the postcards.

DSCN1966

very touristy but striving for a “different” take on the “Sapphire Pool” at Yellowstone National Park.

IMG_0309

a shot from the previously blogged-about explorative hike up into what we hoped would be bear country. in this moment the view felt untouched, and I think represented an appreciation for the park (Yellowstone) not tarnished by its economically relevant beauty.

Environmental Justice from a Few Angles

When we spoke about Central Park in class today, a thought kept nagging at me pertaining to an article I stumbled upon months ago. According to this article, and to articles I located today on the same issue, a portion of Central Park exists on the land formerly known as Seneca Village. Seneca Village was a largely forgotten community comprised of 2/3 African American and 1/3 Irish inhabitants. It was one of the first communities in the United States that housed a majority of African American homeowners. When the park was built, these people were forced from their homes, and by all accounts never re-established the style of lives they had in the Village once they were displaced.

I think it was critical for Central Park to exist, and I think it is integral in the well-being of New York City residents, but when the documentary today began to explore the trends of elitism that pervaded its early populations, I was again left questioning the racial implications of the project and how grand the impact of its construction may have been in the perpetuation of institutional racism and deprivation of resources to African American families.

This article is quick but it kind of lays out some of the frame for why this matters. I think Environmental Justice is really interesting and I think it is something we could explore more in class because so far I would say the majority of our literature has focused on a very white, often male, perspective of the adaptations of land and culture that surround our thoughts on nature and I would be curious to see if we could integrate some other-cultural perspectives in our dealings with what best upholds the marriage between man and land.

 

http://cute-n-tiny.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/3364851456_4a149b2952-400×265.jpg

 

Story of Place Progress Log

Site 5: Simon Silk Mill. Alexa Gatti and Nicole Maksymiw

Our most recent visit to our site was around 6:30-7:00 PM, so we were able to experience the site at a different time with a new perspective. Since this was around dusk, the sky grew progressively darker throughout the visit. We began with plenty of light to see well, but by the end of the visit, it was more difficult to maneuver from the creek bed area back up to the parking lot. This different perspective adds yet another layer to the many that we have been exploring at this site. The only light to illuminate the area at all was artificial light on a building by the road above.

log 3 image1

This visit was a few days after a lot of rain, so the water was flowing a bit higher and much faster than during previous visits. There were more riffles in the water with the faster movement, too. The water level was definitely even higher in recent days, as evidenced by the appearance of the rocky outcropping from which we have explored. This area is full of puddles and leaves, which would have been transported during a time of higher flow.

log image 2

The site is currently evolving to develop a new layer. Evidence of renovation efforts is present with the ongoing construction on the old silk mill. A brand new sign stands out by the driveway to the silk mill, which was not there during any previous visit. This sign was brightly illuminated, so it caught my attention when we first drove past. As we left the site, we pulled over to admire and take a closer look. The lights and newly developed section contrasts the older part of the silk mill. In an image with the sign and the ongoing refurbishments, a window with a broken or missing window is visible.

log image 4log image 3

This week we also began to dig into the history of the Simon Silk. Development along the Bushkill began in the late 1700s. By the end of the 20th century, the R&H Simon Silk Company was the largest producer of black silk ribbon in the world. The Easton mill employed 2,000 workers (www.eastonpartnership.org). The Silk Mill opened in 1883 as the first economic development project in Easton and closed in the late 1960s. The Easton Redevelopment Authority obtained the property in 2006 and VM Development was selected to lead the construction project.

The city of Easton is redeveloping the Simon Silk Mill complex “based in the ideals of adaptive reuse and sustainable development” (www.eastonpartnership.org). The Simon Silk space is being converted into “149 apartments, 50,000 square feet of warehouse space, and 100,000 square feet of mixed use development” (Miller). We are eager to find out what this “mixed use development” will entail. According to VM’s website Silk will be a collaborative space for artists. The City is also working with the Delaware and Lehigh National Heritage Corridor “to design and construct a recreational and heritage trail” to connect downtown Easton to the Simon Silk complex (www.eastonpartnership.org). The current Civil Engineering Capstone class at Lafayette is working to design this connective trail.

To uncover more information about history of the Arts Trail and future development of Simon Silk and this area of the creek, we plan to interview the members of the CE Capstone course and officials of the Delaware and Lehigh National Heritage Corridor.  Professor Brandes provided the names of Dick McAteer (board member of the Greater Easton Development Partnership) and Paul Dearing (key player in the connective trail project)  as contacts. Jim Toia (Lafayette’s director of community-based teaching) has been a major contributor to the Karl Stirner Arts Trail. We hope to interview these individuals along with everyday users of this section of the trail.

Rudy Miller provided photos of the Silk Mill area/development project on Lehigh Valley Live: http://photos.lehighvalleylive.com/express-times/2015/08/the_easton_intermodal_transpor_15.html

http://vmdevelopmentgroup.com/?page_id=159

Story of Place: Update 4

This past week we decided to reinvestigate the history of our sight and specifically the mills that used to be there.

We began by looking at old pictures of the site and happened upon on captioned ‘Old Groetzinger Mill’ and thought to look into this site. This led us to find out that this Groetzinger Mill was actually located at our site at the end of N. 4th Street in Easton across from Goose Island on the Bushkill. The Groetzinger family operated the mill for nearly half a century from the late 19th and early 20th century. This seemed to us to be an excellent example of the unique story of this part of the Bushkill.

FOD_OldGroetzingerMillLookingW_p287v2

Another article we found said that as early as the 1870’s there have been attempts to set up salmon fisheries on the Bushkill because of their ability to benefit the health of the stream. While the stocking of Atlantic salmon in the Bushkill seemed to be relatively unsuccessful, the people of the Easton area were clearly committed to the idea of manipulating nature to their own advantage.

Screen Shot 2015-10-19 at 10.25.07 AM

“this fist is a fact, and in official hands will be irrefutable evidence that the stocking of our rivers with the most valuable fish in the world is not visionary but predictable.”

 

 

 

 

Today however, the remains of these mills are gone and the general respect for the natural benefits of the Bushkill are lacking as well. Both sides of the creek are thoroughly overgrown, making it difficult to find any historical evidence of previous human development. From a natural standpoint, the Bushkill Creek used to be the center of attention in the area, with humans settling and developing in harmony with the creek. Today, it seems as if the community has built up and around the creek, ignoring any potential aesthetic or practical use. The arts building that bridges the creek is symbolic of the idea that Easton no longer values the creek as local residents once did. It has literally been built over, out of sight and out of mind, providing little more than a source of runoff from the surrounding streets or a shelter for the homeless.

On the Downtown side of the creek, next to the parking lot, is an old abandoned building. It is not old enough to have a relation to the Groetzinger Mill, but it may be built over the original area of the mill. It is so close to the water that we wonder if the creek’s banks were filled in to support such a large building.

_DSC4860

 

On a separate note, the foliage along the creek seems to be changing more slowly that the rest of the area. The leaves on the trees are just barely starting to turn, while the ground cover and shrubbery still looks nearly as full and as green as it did in September. The water level also seems to remain relatively steady.

_DSC4835

_DSC4854

 

 

Final thoughts: We learned a bit more about the artwork hanging from the arts building. Stacy Levy created the piece in 2011. “Bushkill Curtain spans the Bushkill Creek in Easton, Pennsylvania, using the arched opening under an old silk mill. The water flow of the creek varies widely depending on rainfall. Bushkill Curtain will register the changing levels of water, hanging straight down in low water or floating on the surface as the stream rises. It also responds to the wind, blowing like a sheer fabric. This temporary project (June 2011 through August , 2012) was created for The Arts in the Urban Environment Festival. This site is a juncture where the masonry of the industrial architecture meets with the liquid nature of a stream. The curtain creates a meeting point of manmade materials with the elements of wind and water. It is made of 750 buoys strung on steel cable.”

 

Credit: Stacy Levy http://stacylevy.com/installations/images/bushkill1.jpg

Credit: Stacy Levy http://stacylevy.com/installations/images/bushkill1.jpg

Quotes from Readings 10/19

From The World Without Us – “With no more people, there won’t be salt. There will, however, be rust and quite a bit of it, when no one is painting the bridges.” (42)

This is specifically speaking of New York City’s bridges that will continue thriving if they are maintained. Similar to most structures in NYC, without the human maintaining them, they will quickly deteriorate at the hand of nature.

From Walden – “At length, having come up fifty rods off, he uttered one of those prolonged howls, as if calling on the god of loons to aid him, and immediately there came a wind from the east and rippled the surface, and filled the whole air with misty rain, and I was impressed if it were the prayer of the loon answered, and his god was angry with me; and so I left him disappearing far away on the tumultuous surface.” (258)

Thoreau in this section believes that the loon he is ‘playing’ with can understand human instinct and the loon ‘himself’ is capable of “calling on the god of loons”. The loon “laughs” and “balks” at Thoreau, so he makes the loon feel like a human almost, yet make sure to distinguish that the loon is an animal and calls upon a different god to answer his prayers.

 

Quotes

“There too I admired, though I did not gather, the cranberries, small waxen gems, pendants of the meadow grass, pearly and red, which the farmer plucks with an ugly rake, leaving the smooth meadow in a snarl, heedlessly measuring them by the bushel and the dollar only, and sells the spoils of the meads to Boston and New York; destined to be jammed, to satisfy the tastes of lovers of Nature there” (Thoreau, 259).

 

“Some people want to put the forest back the way it was 200 years ago,” he says. “To do that, I tell them, you’ve got to put the Bronx back the way it was 200 years ago” (Weisman, 35).

Passages of Interest

Hermit alone. Let me see: where was I? Methinks I was nearly in the frame of mind; the world lay about at this angle. Shall I go to heaven here or go fishing? If I should bring this meditation to an end, would another sweet occasion be likely to offer?” (Thoreau 245).

This passage stood out to me as it seems Thoreau is very clearly pointing out this transcendental moment he is having by himself, that he is in this state at this perfect “angle” for the moment and changing this would jeopardize the important, hard-to-find moment.

“I pursued with a paddle, and he dived, but when he came up I was nearer than before. He dived again, but I miscalculated the direction he would take, and we were fifty rods apart when he came to the surface this time, for I had helped to widen the interval; and again he laughed loud and loud, and with more reason than before” (Thoreau 255).

Throughout this chapter Thoreau gives many of his “neighbors” in the form of animals personality. One example of when I saw this was during his interaction with the loon; I found this perspective that extended personality to the animals around him and to view them as neighbors to be interesting and entertaining.