Lying post

img_8182

I decided to post this photo of my friend to social media. I thought because we have a lot of friends in common that we would be able to get more of a response. A lot of our friends were confused by the topic and wondered why she was hanging upside down. Some thought that she was right side up at first and didn’t realize that it was a complete lie until further examination. I got a few questions on why her face looked distorted before they realized that she was upside down. Overall I got a lot of good responses along with some confusion but it was a successful post!

Post Lying Photographs to Social Media

I posted the photo I took of toy soldiers to the social media. One of my friends commented that the photo showed the war scene, and she asked if it was the day of commemoration of a war. It is surprising to hear that because the truth is quite different from what the photograph tells. Since I played with the scale of the objects, and took the picture from a low angle, the soldiers are seen to be much larger. Also, some people mentioned the black and white color of this photo and they said it was an old picture of a war or from a film. However, some people exposed my trick, and they thought the soldiers were not real but models or sculptures. After posting this lying photograph, I also posted the picture that shows the real scene. The second photo shows a row of tiny toy soldiers by the window. This time people were surprised at the toys’ tiny scale, and some thought that they were fooled. So from this lying photo, I found it interesting to see things from a different angle and take photographs of them

.fullsizerenderimg_3879

Photos that can lie

I posted the one of me carrying my girlfriend on Instagram. People know the fact that’s me carrying her, but then they left comment like “It’s a quite interesting photo.” I would say the “lie” of this photo is not done on purpose. The “lie” of this photo is created accidentally.

img_5804

I asked some of my friends to take a look at photos that I took for classes. For the Lego New York one, everyone knew that this wasn’t real New York city, but they still found it was a interesting one to look at. I think one thing making the Lego NYC compelling is that it is “lying”, but it is also telling viewers the fact of “lying”. The other one with four feet is much more “real” for viewers. It’s trying to hide the truth. These two photos are both “lying photos”, but in different ways.

img_9365 img_7075

Photographs that lie on social media

I posted a picture I took for the “Photographs that Lie” assignment on my Instagram. I use Instagram pretty frequently and felt the photograph was already in-line with a lot of content I typically post. The picture – a photo of my friend Nirupa staring forlornly out of a window, acknowledging the camera – felt like a modern retelling of Rapunzel so I captioned it “Let down your hair.” None of the comments seemed to recognize it was for a photo assignment. One friend commented that she liked the shot, another just commented “lol” and Nirupa aptly replied “or my keys.” It was interesting to see that a staged photograph was accepted as a normal, standard post of mine by most of my friends. I think it would have garnered a different response on Facebook, where it would reach a wider audience. However, it’s pretty standard for people to share art and photos on Instagram in addition to personal photographs so I can see how the lines between a staged and candid photo could blur on Instagram.

img_9111

Photograph I posted on Instagram

-Sadie